Theiling Online    Sitemap    Conlang Mailing List HQ   

Re: Atlantean

From:Andreas Johansson <andjo@...>
Date:Friday, January 9, 2004, 9:16
I wouldn't say the identification is "unmistakable" - certainly alot of more-
or-less clever people have made other identifications! - but I agree the
Minoan hypothesis is the best one.

                                                Andreas

Quoting Garth Wallace <gwalla@...>:

> The best theory of Atlantis I've seen is this one: > <http://www.laketech.com/AD_LC.HTML> > > | In a sense, Atlantis actually existed, and was indeed destroyed by > | the sea in a cataclysmic event, very plausibly lasting a day and a > | night. Plato's account was wrong in several essential ways, but > | was derived from correct, if garbled, historical accounts. Plato's > | writings embodied the now lost words of Solon, a Greek ruler who > | visited Egypt circa 590 BC. Plato's account of Atlantis was thus a > | retelling of the story of Solon, who in turn told the stories that > | he had heard during his trip to Egypt. > | > | In Egypt, Solon heard of the ancient land of Keftiu, a > | island-nation named for holding one of the four pillars that > | supported the Egyptian sky. Keftiu was, according to the Egyptians, > | an advanced civilization that was the gateway to and ruler of all of > | the lands to the far west of Egypt. Keftiu traded in ivory, copper, > | and cloth. Keftiu supported hosts of ships and controlled commerce > | far beyond the Egyptians domain. By Egyptian record, Keftiu was > | destroyed by the seas in an apocalypse. Solon carried this story to > | Greece, and passed it to his son and grandson. > | > | Plato recorded and embellished the story from Solon's grandson > | Critias the younger, translating the land of the pillars which held > | the sky (Keftiu) into the land of the titan Atlas. Keftiu-Atlantis > | was Egypt's gateway to the "western" lands (Greece, Libya, and > | beyond), and was the home of a civilization that held dominion over > | the surronding lands. But Plato mistook the location of Atlantis: > | Atlantis was not west of the Mediterranean, but was merely west of > | Egypt. Yet Plato preserved enough detail about the land of Atlantis > | that its identification is now unmistakeable. Plato never realized > | that the land of Atlantis was already familiar to him: Atlantis was > | the land of the Minoan culture, namely ancient Crete. The Minoan > | culture spread its dominion throughout the nearby islands of the > | Aegean, more than 1500 years BC. >

Replies

John Cowan <cowan@...>
Peter Bleackley <peter.bleackley@...>